[U-Boot] [PATCH] config.mk: add drivers as default include PATH

Macpaul Lin macpaul at gmail.com
Thu Dec 16 13:52:13 CET 2010


Dear Wolfgang,

2010/12/16 Wolfgang Denk <wd at denx.de>:
> Dear Macpaul Lin,

>> 3. There is possibility we initialize device in lowlevel_init.S then
>> reconfigure it in C level code.
>> Such as sdram controller and flash controller.
>
> SDRAM should not be initialized in lowlevel_init.S. Please use the
> (new for ARM, shared with PPC which has always been using this) model
> where RAM initialization is done in dram_init(), i. e. as part of the
> init sequence in arch/arm/lib/board.c
>
>> For example, in "arch/arm/include/asm/arch-at91/at91_mc.h" and
>> in "arch/arm/include/asm/arch-a320/ftsmc020.h"
>> There both exist assembly offset and C type structures.
>> Once other SoC use the same device controller whether in
>> lowlevel_int.S and in board.c, it will have include problem as described in
>> #1 and in #2.
>
> See above - this means that the header file needs to be moved to
> acommon include directory.
>
>> 4. If you execute 'grep -rnH "\.\./\.\./Marvell/" *' in the root of u-boot
>> code,
>> you will find the similar situation about sharing header files with same
>> devices.
>> Includes, pci.h, memory.h, core.h, i2c.h.
>> I guess even these devices is built-in in the SoC (chip), it is better to go
>> to "drivers" folder
>
> drivers is not a common include directory, and thus not the right
> place.
>
>> instead of "board/Marvell/common/".
>
> That may be true.
>
>
>> Since they are configured like a device drivers in a SoC (in board.c or in
>> lowlevel_init.S).
>> I guess they should be put into "drivers" folder.
>
> If this is common driver code, the code itself should be moved to
> drivers (and then, and only then, the header files with the code).
>
> Best regards,
>
> Wolfgang Denk
>

Your opinion is understood.

1. I will trying to make those shared devices being configurable as C drivers
instead of assembly definitions as possible.
2. For those devices which is hard/unnecessary to write a driver,
I will take effort on creating a common folder something like include/faraday
or include/faraday/common to collect those definitions.

-- 
Best regards,
Macpaul Lin


More information about the U-Boot mailing list