[U-Boot-Users] [PATCH] PPC: Use r2 instead of r29 as global data pointer

[Rafal Jaworowski]

Hello Wolfgang,
you wrote:
> R29 was an unlucky choice as with recent toolchains (gcc-4.2.x) gcc
> will refuse to use load/store multiple insns; instead, it issues a
> list of simple load/store instructions upon function entry and exit,
> resulting in bigger code size, which in turn makes the build for a
> few boards fail.
> 
> Use r2 instead.
> 

How about switching r14 (GOT ptr) to r13 in a similar way? Quite like the r2,
r13 is a dedicated register (small data area purposes) and it would let us
avoid using the -ffixed completely.

This would also resolve a general problem with standalone applications that is
lurking in the dark: the global data and GOT pointers are not saved/restored
upon exception/interrupt, so for example, upon a decrementer hit U-Boot code
starts using the dedicated regs blindly, but they could be scratched by the
app's code that was interrupted. This doesn't surface with the U-Boot in-tree
example applications, as they are built using system config.mk and contain
proper -ffixed tweaks and happen to be in sync, but this a general problem,
which should be addressed, as is biting applications built outside of U-Boot
tree..

If we used another dedicated register for GOT purposes, which applications
code would never use by definition, those issues dissapear. Otherwise we need
to provide explicit save/restore in the exception prologue/epilogue.

I can provide patches, but let me know your thoughts first.

kind regards,
Rafal