[U-Boot] [PATCH] axs103: add support of generic OHCI USB 1.1 controller

[Alexey Brodkin]

Hi Marek,

On Thu, 2015-12-17 at 05:01 +0100, Marek Vasut wrote:
> On Wednesday, December 16, 2015 at 08:54:11 PM, Alexey Brodkin wrote:
> > Hi Marek,
> 
> Hi!
> 
> > On Wed, 2015-12-16 at 17:52 +0100, Marek Vasut wrote:
> > > On Wednesday, December 16, 2015 at 05:05:15 PM, Alexey Brodkin wrote:
> > > > This commit adds support of USB 1.1 storage media on AXS103 board.
> > > > For some yet unknown reason USB 2.0 doesn't work on AXS103 board
> > > > issuing messages like this:
> > > > ------------------------>8-------------------
> > > > AXS# usb start
> > > > starting USB...
> > > > USB0:   USB EHCI 1.00
> > > > scanning bus 0 for devices... EHCI timed out on TD - token=0x80008c80
> > > > unable to get device descriptor (error=-1)
> > > > 1 USB Device(s) found
> > > > ------------------------>8-------------------
> > > 
> > > Try defining CONFIG_EHCI_IS_TDI , that _might_ help.
> > 
> > Thanks for that tip but it made no difference to me.
> > I need to look deeper into that problem.
> 
> I remember seeing that stuff multiple times before, but it might be a different 
> issue. It was usually triggered by some sort of corruption during the transfer.
> On ARM, that was often caused by cache issues.

Believe me I know how much of a grief caches bring so the first thing I do
when seeing unexpected behavior I disable caches :)

> > Just a bit of a context here.
> > I'm playing with ARC SP board which consists of 2 parts:
> >  [1] Baseboard with all peripherals and their connectors
> >  [2] Daughterboard with CPU and DDR
> > 
> > Baseboard is connected to CPU-board via AXI tunnel.
> > 
> > And when CPU-board is the one with ASIC based on ARC770
> > that runs at 700 MHz I see USB 2.0 working perfectly fine.
> > 
> > But if I use CPU-board that sports FPGA with ARC HS38 CPU
> > running at 75 MHz I see the first asynchronous tarnsaction
> > on US 2.0 never happens.
> 
> Connect signaltap or chipscope ? :)

Well I don't have either of those tools sitting on my desk but
if absolutely required I'll do that :)

> > In particular in ehci_submit_async() after we enable async. schedule
> > setting CMD_ASE command STS_ASS gets set but then token's status
> > stays active forever i.e. following is always true:
> > --------------------->8---------------------
> > QT_TOKEN_GET_STATUS(token) & QT_TOKEN_STATUS_ACTIVE
> > --------------------->8---------------------
> > 
> > Note USB host controller, phy and usb dongle are exactly the same.
> > And USB 1.1 (OHCI) works perfectly fine at the same time.
> 
> Try adding #define DEBUG at the first line of common/usb.c , so we can get some 
> more debugging info. Also adding the same into common/usb_hub.c helps.

Did that and here's my log:

--------------------->8---------------------
starting USB...
USB0:   ehci_register: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', ctrl=9fd94100, hccr=e0040000, hcor=e0040010, init=0
Register 1111 NbrPorts 1
USB EHCI 1.00
scanning bus 0 for devices... ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe004000
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=256, index=0
USB_DT_DEVICE request
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=5 (0x5), type=0 (0x0), value=1, index=0
USB_REQ_SET_ADDRESS
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=256, index=0
USB_DT_DEVICE request
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=512, index=0
USB_DT_CONFIG config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=512, index=0
USB_DT_CONFIG config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=9 (0x9), type=0 (0x0), value=1, index=0
USB_REQ_SET_CONFIGURATION
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=768, index=0
USB_DT_STRING config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=769, index=1
USB_DT_STRING config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7c000, udev->dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=770, index=1
USB_DT_STRING config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=160 (0xa0), value=10496, index=0
USB_DT_HUB config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=6 (0x6), type=160 (0xa0), value=10496, index=0
USB_DT_HUB config
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=0 (0x0), type=160 (0xa0), value=0, index=0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=3 (0x3), type=35 (0x23), value=8, index=1
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=0 (0x0), type=163 (0xa3), value=0, index=1
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=0 (0x0), type=163 (0xa3), value=0, index=1
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=1 (0x1), type=35 (0x23), value=16, index=1
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=3 (0x3), type=35 (0x23), value=4, index=1
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=0 (0x0), type=163 (0xa3), value=0, index=1
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=1 (0x1), type=35 (0x23), value=20, index=1
Len is 0
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd7b100, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=1
dev=9fd7b100, pipe=80000083, buffer=9fd7ae00, length=64, req=9fd7ad00
req=6 (0x6), type=128 (0x80), value=256 (0x100), index=0
EHCI timed out on TD - token=0x80008c80
dev=0, usbsts=0x1, p[1]=0x1005, p[2]=0x0
unable to get device descriptor (error=-1)
ehci_submit_control_msg: dev='ehci at 0xe0040000', udev=9fd94380, udev->dev='usb_hub', portnr=0
req=1 (0x1), type=35 (0x23), value=1, index=1
Len is 0
1 USB Device(s) found
AXS#
--------------------->8---------------------

Makes any sense?

Note in case of ARC770 the log is very similar except the fact that it goes further to successful
device detection.

-Alexey