[U-Boot] [PATCH 2/4] efikamx: remove drive strength hack from early_init_f and move it to the DCD

[Stefano Babic]

On 17/08/2012 20:19, Matt Sealey wrote:
> The i.MX Boot ROM lets us set up certain registers before U-Boot even gets
> executed. Rather than setting up DDR, putting U-Boot in place, and getting
> into pre-relocation init to set up DDR again, just do it once in the correct
> place. This also solves an issue where the Smarttop DDR pad settings were
> being applied on Smartbook.
> 
> While we're at it, configure PCBID0,1,2 and the LED GPIO since we've still
> got room in the DCD to do so.
> 
> Signed-off-by: Matt Sealey <matt at genesi-usa.com>
> ---

Hi Matt,

> diff --git a/board/genesi/mx51_efikamx/imximage_mx.cfg b/board/genesi/mx51_efikamx/imximage_mx.cfg
> index 6fe0ff9..ac9aa9a 100644
> --- a/board/genesi/mx51_efikamx/imximage_mx.cfg
> +++ b/board/genesi/mx51_efikamx/imximage_mx.cfg
> @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
>  #
> +# Copyright (C) 2009 Pegatron Corporation
                    ^---

Was this added for mistake ? I think you should add only yours.

>  # Copyright (C) 2010 Marek Vasut <marek.vasut at gmail.com>
> -#
> -# BASED ON: imx51evk
> +# Copyright (C) 2009-2012 Genesi USA, Inc.
>  #
>  # (C) Copyright 2009
>  # Stefano Babic DENX Software Engineering sbabic at denx.de.
> @@ -43,48 +43,44 @@ BOOT_FROM	spi
>  #	Address	  absolute address of the register
>  #	value	  value to be stored in the register
>  

I agree with Marek that you break the copyright stuff.

> -# Setting IOMUXC
> -DATA 4 0x73fa88a0 0x000
> -DATA 4 0x73fa850c 0x20c5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa8510 0x20c5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa883c 0x5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa8848 0x5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84b8 0xe7
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84bc 0x45
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84c0 0x45
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84c4 0x45
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84c8 0x45
> -DATA 4 0x73fa8820 0x0
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84a4 0x5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84a8 0x5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84ac 0xe5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84b0 0xe5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84b4 0xe5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84cc 0xe5
> -DATA 4 0x73fa84d0 0xe4
> +# Essential GPIO settings to be done as early as possible
> +# PCBID pad settings are all the defaults except #2 which needs HVE off
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8134 0x3			# PCBID0 ALT3 GPIO 3_16
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8130 0x3			# PCBID1 ALT3 GPIO 3_17
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8128 0x3			# PCBID2 ALT3 GPIO 3_11
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8504 0xe4			# PCBID2 PAD ~HVE
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8198 0x3			# LED0 ALT3 GPIO 3_13
> +DATA 4 0x73fa81c4 0x3			# LED1 ALT3 GPIO 3_14
> +DATA 4 0x73fa81c8 0x3			# LED2 ALT3 GPIO 3_15
>  
> -DATA 4 0x73fa882c 0x4
> -DATA 4 0x73fa88a4 0x4
> -DATA 4 0x73fa88ac 0x4
> -DATA 4 0x73fa88b8 0x4
> +# DDR bus IOMUX PAD settings
> +DATA 4 0x73fa850c 0x20c5		# SDODT1
> +DATA 4 0x73fa8510 0x20c5		# SDODT0
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84ac 0xc5			# SDWE
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84b0 0xc5			# SDCKE0
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84b4 0xc5			# SDCKE1
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84cc 0xc5			# DRAM_CS0
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84d0 0xc5			# DRAM_CS1
> +DATA 4 0x73fa882c 0x2			# DRAM_B4
> +DATA 4 0x73fa88a4 0x2			# DRAM_B0
> +DATA 4 0x73fa88ac 0x2			# DRAM_B1
> +DATA 4 0x73fa88b8 0x2			# DRAM_B2
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84d4 0xc5			# DRAM_DQM0
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84d8 0xc5			# DRAM_DQM1
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84dc 0xc5			# DRAM_DQM2
> +DATA 4 0x73fa84e0 0xc5			# DRAM_DQM3
>  
> -# Setting DDR for micron
> -# 13 Rows, 10 Cols, 32 bit, SREF=4 Micron Model
> -# CAS=3 BL=4
> -# ESDCTL_ESDCTL0
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9000 0x82a20000
> -# ESDCTL_ESDCTL1
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9008 0x82a20000
> -# ESDCTL_ESDMISC
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9010 0xcaaaf6d0
> -# ESDCTL_ESDCFG0
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9004 0x3f3574aa
> -# ESDCTL_ESDCFG1
> -DATA 4 0x83fd900c 0x3f3574aa
> +# Setting DDR for Micron
> +# 13 Rows, 10 Cols, 32 bit
> +# SREF=4 Micron Model CAS=3 BL=4
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9000 0x82a20000 # ESDCTL_ESDCTL0
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9008 0x82a20000 # ESDCTL_ESDCTL1
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9010 0xcaaaf6d0 # ESDCTL_ESDMISC
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9004 0x3f3574aa # ESDCTL_ESDCFG0
> +DATA 4 0x83fd900c 0x3f3574aa # ESDCTL_ESDCFG1
>  
>  # Init DRAM on CS0
> -# ESDCTL_ESDSCR
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x04008008
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x04008008 # ESDCTL_ESDSCR
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x0000801a
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x0000801b
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x00448019
> @@ -110,13 +106,8 @@ DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x0632801c
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x0380801d
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x0040801d
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x00008004
> -
> -# Write to CTL0
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9000 0xb2a20000
> -# Write to CTL1
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9008 0xb2a20000
> -# ESDMISC
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9010 0x000ad6d0
> -#ESDCTL_ESDCDLYGD
> -DATA 4 0x83fd9034 0x90000000
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9000 0xb2a20000 # Write to CTL0
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9008 0xb2a20000 # Write to CTL1
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9010 0x000ad6d0 # ESDMISC
> +DATA 4 0x83fd9034 0x90000000 # ESDCTL_ESDCDLYGD
>  DATA 4 0x83fd9014 0x00000000
> 

I join Marek, it is quite difficult to review it and understand which
was changed. It looks like a new file..

Best regards,
Stefano Babic

-- 
=====================================================================
DENX Software Engineering GmbH,     MD: Wolfgang Denk & Detlev Zundel
HRB 165235 Munich, Office: Kirchenstr.5, D-82194 Groebenzell, Germany
Phone: +49-8142-66989-53 Fax: +49-8142-66989-80 Email: sbabic at denx.de
=====================================================================