[U-Boot-Users] arm SoC code in U-Boot.

[Stefan Roese]

On Tuesday 06 March 2007 23:45, Ulf Samuelsson wrote:
> > When adding "cpu/freescale/" I see no clear line what  should  go  in
> > there  and  what  not.  Whould  we  then  move  all  the  cpu/mpc???/
> > directories into cpu/freescale/  ?  And  then  probably  create  (for
> > consistency)  a  "cpu/amcc/"  directory and mode cpu/ppc4xx into that
> > one? What do we get in addition to another directory level? IMO  that
> > would not improve anything, and you still don't see where shared code
> > is located.
>
> I think you can still keep the cpu/ppc4xx directory but if you
> find that cpu/ppcYYY has shared code with the cpu/ppc4xx
> and you would like to have a common driver, then
> you put it in "cpu/amcc/ppc.
>
> For freescale you would put shared code in
> cpu/freescale/imx and cpu/freescale/ppc
> and maybe cpu/freescale/coldfire

I still think that this code we are talking about here, is most likely some 
driver code for some ethernet controller, or a I2C controller etc. I would 
like to "collect" this sort of driver code, even if it's SoC driver code, 
under the "drivers" directory. This is already done for some drivers but it's 
not done consistently. We already have:

drivers/qe/*
drivers/netarm_eth.*
drivers/omap1510_i2c.*
...

Why not try to match this a little more to the Linux directory structure:

drivers/net/netarm_eth.*
drivers/net/qe/*
drivers/i2c/omap1510_i2c.*
...

From my understanding the drivers mentioned above will fit in here much better 
than in some cpu directories. Just my 0.02$.

BTW: I know it's always a problem to "move" code in a version control system 
because of the revision history.

Best regards,
Stefan

=====================================================================
DENX Software Engineering GmbH, HRB 165235 Munich, CEO: Wolfgang Denk
Office:  Kirchenstr. 5,       D-82194 Groebenzell,            Germany
=====================================================================