[U-Boot] U-Boot git usage model

[Tom Rini]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On 10/13/12 15:25, Wolfgang Denk wrote:
> Dear Tom,
> 
> In message <5079D95E.4070609 at ti.com> you wrote:
>> 
>> While also IANAL (and I try and stay out of these discussions), 
>> paging around in the kernel log it sure seems like Linus and
>> akpm both add S-O-B when they git am something in (perhaps why
>> there is git am --signoff?) but not when it comes via pull
>> request.  In other words, up until the point it goes into 
>> intended-to-be-pulled-somehow-someway git, whomever is
>> presenting the work adds one (or more) to say I (we) worked on it
>> and yes, applies as well as the person bringing it in (I touch
>> this and believe it to be).
> 
> Yes, git am has such an option.  But git fetch (or pull) does not. 
> I see no technical difference if someone provides me a patch as 
> such, or in form of a git repository with this patch applied so I 
> can just "git fetch" from it.  In both cases the result would be 
> exactly the same: I add the patch to my local repository.  But in 
> one case I am supposed to sign it (and tools offer me options to
> do so), but in the other case I cannot do that, even if I wanted?

I will not claim the kernel practice to be 100% consistent, but yes.
git am --signoff, git pull/merge and no -s in merge commits seems to
be the practice.  Perhaps we should stop saying we follow the kernel
process, link to it as useful background, but then document what we
actually want / do which is only require new S-O-B on code
modification, and allow custodians to add their own they want for
tracking or otherwise ease of not having to remember a different
workflow for kernel vs U-Boot?

- -- 
Tom
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=5YMo
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----